DISRUPT Worship Project
  • Home
  • Lent 2021: Christ Have Mercy
  • Biblical Commentary
    • RCL
    • Narrative >
      • The Grief Lectionary
  • Liturgy
    • Lent >
      • Year C
      • Lent: Kindom >
        • Seasonal Liturgical Elements
    • Litanies, confessions, prayers for justice
    • Music
    • New Years Eve Confession
    • Advent >
      • Advent A
      • Advent 2020: Hope
      • Advent C >
        • Advent Wreath Lighting Litanies
        • Confession and Absolution
        • Advent 1
        • Advent 2
    • Christmas Eve
    • Pentecost 2017 >
      • Christ the King 2017
      • October 22
      • October 15
      • October 8
      • October 1
    • Occasional Liturgies >
      • Ritual of Healing, Hope and Blessing for Pregnancy after Loss
    • Full worship services >
      • Full Worship Services Archive
  • A Year of Faithful Resistance
    • Not that kind of revelation
    • Fight
    • A Year Of Saturday
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

Commentary for January 28th, 2018

1/28/2018

 
by Collette Broady Grund
John 3:1-21

There’s a lot to love about this story of Nicodemus, and there’s a lot of resist. Let’s start with resistance, as I’m still feeling a little fiesty from last week:

  1. Resisting the duality of flesh and spirit: this is one of the most difficult things about John’s gospel for me (and it applies to Pauline letters often as well). There seems to be this set up of flesh against spirit, as in flesh is bad and spirit is good. And frankly, most people find it easier to understand if it is that clear a duality.  However, I don’t think that John means it this way, and that’s especially clear in this story. Nicodemus tries to make the distinction clear cut with his literal question about crawling back up the birth canal and being born again, and it is Jesus who resists that literalism. In his words about wind/spirit, he reminds us that the spiritual affects the physical and vice versa. They cannot be separated. Rather than a duality, it’s more helpful to think about this as a tension between two poles.​
  2. Resisting the duality of light and darkness: here I’m just going to point you to Elizabeth’s thorough article from December about the ways that our light and darkness language subtly (and unsubtly) reinforce white supremacy.
  3. Resisting the “decision for Jesus” tendency of John 3:16: This famous verse taken out of context is often used to tell people they need to make a decision to believe in Jesus so that they can be saved instead of perishing. This reading is only possible when the verse is separated from the story of Nicodemus. Remember that this is just the first step in the process of becoming a follower of Jesus for Nicodemus. Here he comes secretly and goes away with more questions than he brought, but he reappears in chapter seven, still a Pharisee but defending Jesus’ right to a fair hearing. Finally, he appears as a follower after the crucifixion, brave enough to go with Joseph of Arimathea to ask for Jesus’ body.

Read More

Commentary for January 21, 2018

1/16/2018

 
By Rev. Collette Broady Grund
John 2:13-25

I’m just going to assume that Jesus is angry here. I know the text doesn’t say that, and scholars are back and forth on it. But I need Jesus to be angry here, at the temple system that turns what should be a sanctuary into a market-driven economic center. I need Jesus to be angry here, angry at the misguided idea that there’s some special place where you need to curry God’s favor and the only way to do that is by buying something alive and killing it. I need Jesus to be angry, because I am angry. And I could really use a good example of what to do with this anger that is both holy and productive.

Read More

Epiphany 2b

1/8/2018

 
by Rev. Collette Broady Grund

John 2:1-11 The Wedding at Cana: The First Sign

To follow the theme for this season of “emBodied” into the gospel of John seemed a daunting proposition at first. This is most dualistic of the gospels, with it’s flesh versus spirit and light verses dark. Jesus is the most perfect in this gospel, with his inexhaustible peace and resignation as he moves toward his own death. Yet, here in chapter two, in the first of his signs, Jesus is decidedly earthy. He’s at a party, which in this pastor’s experience, is always a place ripe with opportunities for ministry!
    I also love the conversation he has with his mother about whether or not he’s going to do anything to save the day. Now I know that “woman” was a traditional way to speak to a female in his time, but his own mother? Other commentators might resist interpreting this as attitude, but as a mother whose own son has called her “woman”, I can’t hear it any other way. In my hearing, there’s always a “Geez” before the “woman”. Even though she only stated the facts of the day, “They have no wine.” Jesus’ resistance to doing something about the problem is what makes him human in this text. Maybe he’s thinking this moment is too small for his great unveiling, maybe he’s wishing he had more time before IT begins, maybe he was just having a good time with his disciples after finally getting away from that obnoxious John, who keeps pointing at him and yelling, “BEHOLD! THE LAMB OF GOD”.
    But his dear mother knows who he is, what he is, and will not take no for an answer. “Do whatever he tells you” she says, and you can almost hear Jesus’ eye roll as he accepts that this actually is his hour, and the wine actually is his concern.
    In a gospel short on details so far, John spends an inordinate amount of space covering the extra proportions of the jars, the amount of water and Jesus’ instructions. He wants us to pay attention to the concrete details, the tangible facts of this sign. Twenty or thirty gallons, six times over, empty jars filled to the brim. If you hear eucharistic echoes in this story, connections to both to the conversation with the woman at the well and the feeding of the 5000, that’s intentional. Though there’s no last supper in John, the superabundance of God’s fullness is everywhere. Jesus is the good wine, he is the water of life gushing up to eternal life, he is the bread of life which comes down from heaven and gives life to the world.
    Mysterious as this sign may be, and frustrating as his roundabout answers in John’s gospel are, Jesus is nevertheless present most clearly in the simple things of life: wine, water, bread. But in Jesus, the superabundance of these simple things points beyond them to the greater reality of God’s reign, God’s own self taking on human form, finite things which contain the infinite.
    For preaching, there are two possible directions that appeal to me. First, the focus on Jesus’ resistance to this first sign, and Mary’s quiet insistence that he do something. There are countless times in our following Jesus where an opportunity arises unexpectedly, maybe even at a party just trying to have a good time, and we feel our own resistance to the work of God rise up. “This isn’t the time to talk about serious things.” “That’s none of my business.” “I’m not on the clock.” In those moments where we resist the inbreaking of God’s work, who are the ones to help us see that the hour is NOW, and that God’s concerns and ours are one and the same? Who are the ones that call us to action when we’d rather look the other way?
    Second, the superabundance of wine calls to me. It’s hard even to imagine 120 or 150 gallons of wine. It’s an excess, embarrassing to the bridegroom and his family, wildly inappropriate to the occasion. Yet Jesus does it, quietly as if it’s no big deal, and walks away without comment. Think about that: such a huge quantity of excellent wine, worth thousands of dollars today, is not even worth commenting upon in the greater view of God’s reign! Is there anywhere in our lives that we experience such superabundance? Is there anywhere in the church?
    My recent ministry with the people of my community has been to open a homeless shelter that rotates a week at at time between seven congregations. As little as a year ago, this seemed a completely improbable dream. Yet, everywhere we have turned, God’s abundance has appeared. Literally every day I walk into my office to a pile of donated coats, hats and blankets, to checks from those the Spirit has moved to generosity. Every night, twenty five people show up at one of our churches to a warm bed and copious amounts of food prepared by volunteers. This kind of hospitality can only be God’s work, as it far outpaced my expectations months ago. It’s not gallons of wine in this sign, it’s piles of fleece tie-blankets under which the bodies of Christ’s body finally have a warm place to sleep this winter.
    This is the Narrative Lectionary sermonizing archive.

    Archives

    October 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

All liturgy and litanies are for public use, c. Disrupt Worship Project (or DWP).  If any changes are made to the liturgy, [adapted by ____] must be included in the attribution. If an individual author is cited, please include their name as well. Email team@disruptworshipproject.com with any further questions or permissions.

Help us to keep creating liturgy, litanies and commentaries that lift up new voices and push towards justice -- become a patron of Disrupt on Patreon!
Support us on Patreon

© COPYRIGHT 2015. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Home
  • Lent 2021: Christ Have Mercy
  • Biblical Commentary
    • RCL
    • Narrative >
      • The Grief Lectionary
  • Liturgy
    • Lent >
      • Year C
      • Lent: Kindom >
        • Seasonal Liturgical Elements
    • Litanies, confessions, prayers for justice
    • Music
    • New Years Eve Confession
    • Advent >
      • Advent A
      • Advent 2020: Hope
      • Advent C >
        • Advent Wreath Lighting Litanies
        • Confession and Absolution
        • Advent 1
        • Advent 2
    • Christmas Eve
    • Pentecost 2017 >
      • Christ the King 2017
      • October 22
      • October 15
      • October 8
      • October 1
    • Occasional Liturgies >
      • Ritual of Healing, Hope and Blessing for Pregnancy after Loss
    • Full worship services >
      • Full Worship Services Archive
  • A Year of Faithful Resistance
    • Not that kind of revelation
    • Fight
    • A Year Of Saturday
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact